“Ever has it been that love knows not its own depth until the hour of separation.” –Kahlil Gibran
“So it’s true, when all is said and done, grief is the price we pay for love.” –E.A. Bucchianeri, Brushstrokes of a Gadfly
Hello friend,
I had said my last goodbyes in a parking lot a few minutes before, knowing traffic would be hairy by her dorm and that I would have to stay in the car. While my wife and son got into their seats, I had squeezed my newly-18-year-old daughter as hard as I dared and wept into her hair. I had tried to press all the right words into her ear before it was too late and we had to let go. Then, as we both realized there was nothing else to do, I had eased up on my hug and pressed my lips to her forehead, neither of us able to speak by that point. So we got in the car—she in the back and me in the front–and I drove the few blocks to her dorm, the car totally silent except for my sniffling. My eyes were fully pouring out tears as if two faucets were left on. I knew she was trying to compose herself before she stepped out onto the curb of her new dorm, under the bright streetlights where she might be recognized by someone from her floor who might be passing by. I pulled through the stoplight and up to the corner just past the crosswalk, not quite far enough out of the intersection for a real parking spot. I touched the button for my hazard lights so I wouldn’t get a ticket. Right in front of us, another family was piling out of their minivan to say their final goodbyes as well. I smiled through my tears. It looked beautiful to see someone else do it. My wife and son opened their doors to signal it was time and they all got out. I watched my daughter close the door and step out onto the curb near the back wheel. I kept looking back over my shoulder at the three of them through the window, group hugs and individual hugs and tears and smiles over what I knew were forced jokes and my wife trying to hold it together so my daughter could hold it together. I was there in the dark silence of an empty car watching through a closed window like it was a scene in a movie that breaks your heart because you love the characters so much and hate what’s happening to them. I was sobbing and huffing, not really in any kind of control of myself. After a while, when I figured they must be finishing soon, I finally composed myself just enough to push the button to roll down the back passenger window to yell one more time that I love her. It came out all wild and fading—like monster-speak–my strength leaving me just as I felt the words begin to burst out. I rolled it right back up and collapsed in my seat. Then, unwilling to miss even a second, I turned back and watched them all collect themselves. My daughter wiped her tears and steadied herself, nodding that she was ready. They gave a final squeeze. And just like that, she turned and began the long walk down the sidewalk to the entrance of the dorm. I knew this was it, the moment I had been preparing her to embrace and the moment I had been most dreading for the last eighteen years. The best eighteen years of my life. I was blubbering, she becoming a blur through my steady tears. “There she goes….” I whispered as my heart burst. She never looked back.
I put the car in gear and slowly pulled away from the curb, making my way through the busy city streets in the dark night back to our lodgings. I was hollowed out, empty, unable even to whimper anymore. The car was dead silent as we made our way. Some minutes later, it all rose up again in me. Trying to keep myself together for the drive, I shook silently but violently as the tears poured harder than ever. I knew that this is what driving would be like after this—the absence of her.
The next morning, as we turned the car away from her new city and back toward home—two full days of driving away–that profound emptiness and quiet filled the car again. As the gorgeous countryside floated by in the sunshine out the window, inside the car it was grey and somber. For the first time we were all fully aware that with every minute, we were getting further and further away from the glue of our family, that the empty seat next to my son was really a gaping hole in our hearts. It would never be the same. It all seemed so wrong, so clearly unjust.
“Why???”
That’s the word that kept coming into my mind as I drove, the word that kept agitating me. WHY did we agree to this? WHY does a happy family choose to separate from each other? WHY couldn’t it have been closer, like the other families I know? But mostly this: WHY does the best thing for her growth and her future feel like the worst thing for me?
I didn’t give over to the idea of parenthood easily. I always adored kids, but I didn’t think I had it in me to sacrifice my passions and pursuits for the sake of others. I watched my siblings and friends do it, and while I loved their kids, I couldn’t imagine myself fully responsible for these magical little creatures and their magnificent lives. So I came late and begrudgingly to the decision to make a family. Then fertility issues entered the picture, leaving me wondering about whether fatherhood was in the cards for me after all. In the end, there was no one more grateful in the world than me when my daughter arrived eighteen years ago. I was over the moon for that girl from the first moment. Nothing about that has changed in the ensuing years. I redesigned my entire life around her schedule to maximize every moment. I couldn’t bear the idea of missing anything. And I didn’t. For whatever amount of career advancement or accolades or social life I might have missed out on, none of it mattered even the tiniest amount compared to the joy and fulfillment of being in her world, basking in her light. It filled my whole heart.
That empty feeling in the car on the long drive back across the land. The even more desolate feeling in the house when we finally arrived back home. The silence. The utter barrenness inside me as I walked around in her bedroom. All of that emptiness could only be filled by the sweet girl who I left on the sidewalk on the other side of the country last week. She is the size of my heart.
Of course, I knew it was coming. My heart has been slowly crumbling all year. It was my resolution from the start of her senior year of high school to be present, to stay in the moment, to not be the one crying at every event and sad about how fast it was all going. I didn’t want to risk missing all the great stuff she was doing because I was mourning her absence in advance. And I didn’t want her feeling responsible for the care-taking of my feelings; that’s not a child’s job. I was pretty successful at it, surprisingly. I took in all the moments and appreciated every second with her, right up until that moment at the curb. Maybe I was too present. Maybe if I had done more mourning during the year it wouldn’t hurt so much now.
I don’t know how this is happening all over the world every year and people are surviving it. How many people that I come across in the normal course of my day are absolutely shattered inside from the loss of their own hearts? How are they doing it? My sister texted me as we were setting up my daughter’s dorm room a few days before that awful night at the curb. She had been through this torture with a few of her own kids and was aware of my crumbling, so she was being a good big sister and checking in on me. She said of her first college drop-off, “I remember being almost angry that no one explained in advance how wholly gut-wrenching it was. I was literally sick.” Exactly!
I have been alternately trying to explain this probably-silent epidemic to myself and trying to tell a story of how my pain must be exceptional. On the one hand, people are letting their loved ones go in different ways all through life. I remember how shredded my wife was when she first dropped my daughter off at daycare, even though she knew she would return in a couple of hours to nurse. After having the whole Summer with my kids every year, each first day of school has always felt somewhat tragic to me. But also, parents are saying goodbye to their kids as they go off to the military, which is not only far but potentially dangerous. That sounds horrible! Other college kids go across the world for a semester or a year. Some young adults just move out and live with their friends. Some get jobs elsewhere. Some get married. Whatever the case, we get this knowing feeling that the special thing we have had with our kid is about to be forever changed. Sure, we will have other things with them, but never this thing, the first thing. They don’t live with us anymore. It is rightfully devastating for any parent.
But then I try to get precious about my own pain. I think about why mine is surely worse. For one, in realizing how lucky I was to get to design my life entirely around my kids’ schedules, I see the flipside and how that closeness and single-mindedness has perhaps left me without alternative support systems when they inevitably go away, leaving me rudderless and adrift at sea, lost without them. And then there is the distance thing. I can’t help but compare myself to my friends who are dropping their children at colleges on the other side of our city or a few hours away in the next state, where they can get to them with an easy car ride if they need a hug or a family dinner. I’m sure they are suffering, too, and I feel badly for them, but can it really be in the same ballpark as me dropping my kid on the other side of the country??? I feel singled out for this particularly brutal kind of torture. Surely I am being punished for some despicable deed in my past.
But just when I am getting swamped in self-indulgence, I am reminded how life was not so long ago. Once upon a time, if a kid went off to school across the country, you were left to simply imagine their life: what their room looked like, who their friends were, if they were healthy. Hopefully they would send letters. That must have been excruciating for parents! Later, the phone became an option, but long-distance calls were expensive (and certainly rare in my house). Maybe parents would send a care package, but that didn’t mean you could envision the child’s life. That was an improvement but must have been still awful for moms and dads. Now, with the magic of smartphones (and a compassionate daughter), at least I can get regular updates that help me to paint a picture of how she is living over there while I am sulking about her not living here. I get texts about her classes and what she is having for dinner. I got a verbal check-in after the first day of classes. From her photos, I am beginning to put names to the faces of some of her new friends. We even did a family FaceTime, which did wonders for my aching heart. (And when she stops being so forthcoming, at least I can still follow her on Instagram.) All of these little moments of connection and all of these details that provide color to the picture of her new world help to take the edge off for me. It’s not just, “I live here, and she does NOT live here,” (though it is kind of like that, I hate to admit). I’m just saying it could be worse. I am grateful it’s not.
I’ve been back home for over a week now since that last night at the curb. I’ve had some time for this new reality to settle in. The Verdict: Life was simply better when she was around. It’s too quiet now, too empty. I hurt every time I pass by her room. Everything reminds me of her. My wife taped one of those giant cardboard photo heads of my daughter to her chair at the dinner table, where she used to eat and do all her homework. It makes me smile every time I look at it, but then it also wrings out my heart like a rag. I feel like an empty shell going through the motions in the dark, missing that thing that lit up the room and my heart for eighteen straight years. That light lives across the country from me now. I left it there on the curb almost two weeks ago. And even though I am certain I did the right thing—she will learn to shine even brighter there and build her own beautiful adult life—right now I just feel heartbroken. It turns out Love is a real beast.
How about you? Have you ever willingly let go of the thing you love the most? Grab a pen or a keyboard and write about a time when you agreed to allow your heart to be ripped from your chest. Maybe the first thing that comes to your mind is a romantic break-up, but for me those belong in a different category (and they are usually better for both parties). Which willing goodbyes have torn you apart, knowing things will never be the same? Have you had a close friend move away from you at any age? Have you had to move a loved one to a care facility knowing they were better off there? Ever have a friend or roommate get married and know your relationship will be forever changed? Have you sent someone off to the military? If you have kids, which separations have most broken your heart? Daycare? Kindergarten? Middle school? Summer camp? No longer driving them? High school? Have you gone through this college drop-off experience? Was it as devastating for you as it currently is for me? Does the pain just continue to grow as they form their own adult lives more and more independently of you? Have you found anything to fill the hole in your heart? Is the rest of life just a neverending pursuit of distraction from the pain after this point? Do you have any advice for me? Leave me a reply and let me know: Have you ever left your heart on a curb?
Savor every moment,
William
P.S. If this topic resonated with you today, please share it with your community. Let’s help each other to feel less alone and to see all the ways our hearts can be filled.
P.P.S. If this way of examining your life appeals to you, consider buying my book, Journal of YOU: Uncovering The Beauty That Is Your Truth, at your favorite online retailers. Namaste.








